How Healthcare Data Archiving Solutions Can Reduce Technical Debt During M&A Activities

by | Jul 26, 2024 | Blog

Every organization faces the challenge of technical debt, but it’s especially tough for hospitals and health systems. Managing hundreds of IT applications is not easy, especially when each one plays a critical role.

Technical debt refers to the future costs and inefficiencies resulting from maintaining outdated IT applications. Over time, these applications become increasingly difficult to support, leading to higher maintenance costs and less flexibility for innovation. Following a merger or acquisition, the complexity of managing these applications increases exponentially.

According to healthcare Kaufman Hall, hospital and health M&A activity increased 23% in 2023, with 65 announced transactions. As operating margins continue to decline, more hospitals under financial stress are likely to seek mergers.

A global survey of 1,000 tech executives shows that organizations spend more than 30% of their IT budgets and more than 20% of their IT personnel resources on addressing technical debt. Further, nearly 70% believe that dealing with technical debt hampers the ability to innovate.

Driving M&A Success with Healthcare Data Archiving Solutions

Hospitals use hundreds, if not thousands, of IT applications to care for patients, track finances, manage infrastructure, and plan for future growth, which makes reducing technical debt through retiring outmoded applications an ongoing activity. But when a hospital acquires a physician practice, an ambulatory care facility, or another hospital, that technical debt compounds considerably.

Having been involved in M&A activities for years, I’ve seen firsthand the critical role that a robust archiving strategy plays in helping healthcare organizations manage technical debt, retire legacy applications, and ensure the data is optimally retained for continued and future use.

Based on my experience, here are several best to help healthcare organizations address these challenges and maximize potential value in M&A, while protecting patient records from data loss or breaches by maintaining data integrity.

1. Understand Your Software Landscape

Every organization has software applications that have seen better days. Often, a newer application has been implemented, but the old one remains necessary for historical reasons or due to incompatibility with the new EHR/EMR. The first step in any application archival strategy is to fully understand the software application landscape—both current and historic.

This can be particularly challenging in a hospital environment due to the sheer number of applications and their disparate uses. For instance, diagnostic imaging software is only used by radiologists, and historic PACS may get overlooked during the software survey.

This is where application rationalization becomes crucial. It involves conducting a thorough inventory of all applications to identify overlaps, redundancies, and outdated ones for potential archival. Millions of dollars are often wasted on IT applications that are little used, if at all. When left under the radar, these applications not only bloat your tech stack, but they also increase the cyber-attack surface.

When deciding what should be archived, your organization should consider the volume of legacy data, number of legacy applications, compliance, data governance policies, data security, and costs. Many organizations mistakenly focus on archiving high-value IT applications containing clinical and patient data, choosing to delay archival of older, smaller applications.

While high value applications are important, prudent organizations recognize the value of all software applications. As Dr. Kel Pults, Chief Clinical Officer and Vice President, Government Strategy at MediQuant says, “Healthcare leaders should avoid stepping over a dollar to save a dime. Properly managing and archiving your IT applications now can prevent much larger expenses down the road.”

Dr. Pults recommends starting application rationalization early in the M&A process. She says, “The insights from your inventory are helpful to create a realistic EMR/EHR archiving budget. It can also inform your transition services agreement, ensuring you’ve set data transfer deadlines that match the scope and complexity of your IT environment.”

2. Define Your Data Retention Requirements

Data retention requirements can vary widely, depending on the type of legacy data and the state(s) where a health system operates. Many healthcare organizations lack insight into these requirements, making it challenging to accurately account for them during negotiations. Generally, medical records should be kept for 10 years after the last encounter or a patient’s death. In some states, childhood medical records are required to be retained for 10 years beyond the age of majority/consent, which means nearly 30 years. Through the increasing use of artificial intelligence, health systems are rediscovering the value of leveraging patient data for research and uncovering treatment trends and their effect on outcomes. Medical records also need to be retained for medical release of information requests. Financial and operational data is finding new life beyond the usual seven- to 10-year retention policies the IRS, Joint Commission, and other entities often impose. Healthcare leaders should carefully examine their organizational needs and objectives for medical, financial, and operational data. This will ensure compliance with retention and health data storage requirements and help guide thoughtful software retirement.

3. Set Realistic Data Transfer Deadlines During M&A Transactions

Once the acquisition is complete, a clock starts ticking on how soon the acquired organization’s applications will be migrated to the new owner. For-profit companies, especially, want the assets transferred quickly. Failure to do so after the agreed-upon amount of time may result in financial penalties until the transfers are complete. Depending on the complexity of your IT environment, migration could take a year or more. EHR/EMR migration is particularly time-consuming. Any negotiations should include a comprehensive listing of all IT assets that will be part of the sale, including the interdependencies between applications. Effective transition service agreements that specify timelines and responsibilities for data transfer to the new EHR/EMR are crucial. Guidance from a solid archival partner will streamline this process. Look for one with extensive experience in clinical, patient accounting, and health information management (HIM) applications. They should have a strong focus on data stewardship, extensive experience working with major HIS vendors and homegrown applications, and a track record archiving large volumes of diverse datasets.

4. Build a Healthcare Data Archiving Core Competency

Having the right skills, people, partners, and processes in place is essential to manage legacy data effectively. Cross-disciplinary teams that include clinicians, financial staff, IT, HIM, and legal staff can offer valuable perspectives on various aspects of your archival strategy.

Sometimes, hiring external workers may be necessary, which should be considered in your planning and budgeting. A healthcare data archive partner can help set priorities and oversee the effort.

In a recent panel discussion with several CIOs from leading healthcare systems and hospitals, MediQuant President and CEO, Jim Jacobs, offered advice to healthcare leaders undergoing archival during mergers or acquisitions.

He said, “By involving diverse stakeholders and filling gaps in skills through training and partnerships, organizations can build a strong archiving competency that meets immediate needs and sets the foundation for the future. The best practices are where CIOs have tremendous support from their executive colleagues. It’s [archival] viewed as a system. Leveraging organizations like CHIME (The College of Health Information Executives) and others to help more CIOs build competencies around these areas is tied to hard ROI.”

Be Aggressive in Tackling Technical Debt with Healthcare Data Archiving Solutions

More than half (56%) of respondents to a global tech survey said outdated technology and technical debt contribute significantly to wasted IT budgets, with another 43% pointing to redundant applications. The majority note that up to 20% of their current IT budget is wasted, and 25% say the waste tops 20%.

Hospitals face unique challenges with technical debt — even without mergers and acquisitions. Information must be available 24/7/365 to effectively care for patients. By understanding the software application landscape thoroughly, adhering to data retention standards, building a core competency on archiving, and setting realistic migration timelines, hospitals and health systems can tackle technical debt successfully. This creates a more secure computing environment, frees up data for new uses, and saves the organization valuable money by retiring legacy maintenance contracts.

Take this client example: When Greenville Hospital System and Palmetto Health merged to create Prisma Health—the largest nonprofit healthcare system in South Carolina—they needed to standardize on the Epic EHR, which required moving from Cerner Millennium. This kicked off an aggressive project to archive clinical and financial applications to meet regulatory requirements while providing clinicians Epic access.

Like many organizations undergoing a major M&A, Prisma faced challenges along the way. Early in the project, they discovered that archiving medical records from one system might require separate migrations for financial, acute care, and ambulatory data. But, with MediQuant’s expert archival guidance, Prisma Health overcame this hurdle and managed to save $14 million in annual maintenance and labor costs. After completing over 60 migrations (so far), Prisma has saved more than $1,000,000 in historic accounts receivables that would otherwise have been lost.

Are you Planning or Undergoing a Merger or Acquisition?

Learn how MediQuant’s Healthcare Data Archiving Solutions can deliver significant cost savings to your organization, while reducing risk.

More Thought-Leadership

Tapping the Potential of Legacy Data

Tapping the Potential of Legacy Data

According to the Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society (HIMSS), 73% of healthcare provider organizations have legacy applications. As health systems become more intentional about retaining data from these applications, views on the role of legacy data...

Contact Us Today